Indiana University Student Sports Media


December 16, 2011

Early offseason report: The Second Tier

With all the buzz surrounding the top three superstar free agents this offseason, it has been easy to forget about all the other superb players signing contracts at this time.  To keep you up to date on the happenings thus far, I have evaluated the MLB transactions to show you the importance of a few guys not named Albert Pujols, Jose Reyes, or Prince Fielder that you are still going to consistently be watching highlights of next year on Baseball Tonight.


C.J. Wilson, Los Angeles Angels

While Wilson did get a bit of attention as what many would consider the best starting pitcher on the market this offseason, he still has not reached superstardom, and was too quickly forgotten about as “the other guy the Angels got.” On almost any other team, Wilson would have been their biggest offseason acquisition, and someone who the fans would rally around to help bring their team a pennant. His five-year, $77.5 million dollar deal should speak for his abilities.

Wilson had a career year in 2011, ranking in the top 10 of every positive pitching statistic in the AL. With 16 wins, 206 strikeouts, 3 complete games, and a 2.94 ERA, Wilson demonstrated he has all the makings of a Major League Ace. He joins a team with the run support of an above average lineup thanks to the signing of a certain first baseman, and will again be pitching in a division with the Oakland A’s and the Seattle Mariners. Expect to hear C.J. Wilson’s name on a regular basis this year, as he will certainly earn himself more buzz than he received after signing his contract a few hours after The Machine.


Mark Buehrle, Miami Marlins

Just like Wilson, Buehrle was only the second best player signed to his new team this offseason. Quickly forgotten about by the hype surrounding the signing of Shortstop Jose Reyes last week, he will soon remind Marlins fans of why the team threw their payroll limits out the window and signed him to a four-year, $58 million dollar contract.

His consistency is what makes him so valuable. Buehrle has ten consecutive seasons of ten or more wins, only the third active pitcher to accomplish this. He has an impressive resume including a one-hitter against the Rangers in 2007, and the eighteenth perfect game in MLB history thrown on July 23, 2009. Had it not been for the one walk to Sammy Sosa in the ’07 game, he would have become the first pitcher in history to throw two perfect games. He also established a major league record for number of consecutive hitters retired in 2009, at 45 consecutive hitters retired. His glove is as good as his arm, and because of this Buehrle has won three straight Golden Glove awards in ‘09-11. He has one of the best Web Gems of all time, a between the legs, glove flip from foul territory to first base, that led to the creation of the “Buehrle-meter,” to which all other Web Gems were compared to in the 2010 season. Needless to say, this guy deserved more time on the spotlight, but is sure to wow Miami fans in the upcoming 2012 season.


David Ortiz, Boston Red Sox

Maybe because he’s still on the same team, maybe because he is 36 years old, or maybe because he is no longer “the guy” for the Red Sox, David “Big Papi” Ortiz was all but completely ignored this offseason when he accepted salary arbitration from Boston promising his return for 2012. A one sentence storyline on ESPN’s bottom line was about all the attention “the greatest clutch-hitter in the history of the Boston Red Sox” received when the decision was announced. Neither Ortiz nor the Sox have ruled out the possibility of a multi-year deal still being worked out before the arbitration hearing.

People keep waiting for and expecting the end of Big Papi’s career as the Red Sox DH. While we will never see the 2005-06 Ortiz of 50 homeruns and 130+ RBI’s again, we are still seeing a consistently productive player at the plate. Last season he posted the second highest batting average of his career at .309, and got himself into position to help his team score by having an on base percentage of .398. Batting slightly lower in the lineup these days, Ortiz still manages to drive in runs in bunches. He finished his 2011 season with 40 doubles, 29 homeruns, and 96 RBI’s. His bat is still feared, and nestled into a lineup with almost no weak spot, another .300/30/100 season could definitely still be in this old veteran’s tank.


Jonathan Papelbon, Philadelphia Phillies

Signed, sealed, and delivered a month ago, people were not even thinking baseball offseason yet when Papelbon agreed to a four-year, $50 million dollar contract with the Phillies. As soon as the winter meetings began, all the talk was about the superstar free agents that had not signed yet, as it still will be for the next few weeks. It will not be until the dust starts to settle that people will remember this signing, and what it means for the already historic Philadelphia pitching staff.

As the closer for the Boston  Red Sox, Papelbon became the fastest pitcher in MLB history to reach 200 career saves. He is the only pitcher to record 25 saves in each of his first five full seasons, and blew that away by recording at least 35 a season in that time span. He also proves his clutch factor by holding the Major League record for most consecutive scoreless innings to start a postseason career at 25 innings. The 31 year-old shows no sign of slowing down as he posted the most strikeouts of his career last season by striking out 87 batters in 64.1 innings. He also tied a career record by only blowing 3 saves over the duration of the season. His skills will provide the nail in the coffin at the end of games for the Phillies’ superb starting rotation, and he is prime to reach 40+ saves by the end of the 2012 season.


Matt Moore, Tampa Bay Rays

Matt signed a five-year, $14 million dollar deal a few days ago with the Tampa Bay Rays. The deal also allows club options that could make the contract worth $37.5 million over 8 years, numbers that are more reflective of what this 22 year old is really worth. This contract was overshadowed by the bigger negotiations this week, but will prove to be quite important over the duration of its five-year span. Moore is one of the highest rated prospects in all of baseball, and when he got his chance in The Show, he lived up to every bit of it.

His first major league start was against the weak New York Yankees lineup, in the friendly away atmosphere of Yankee Stadium, in mid-September when the Rays had little to play for… Okay, all sarcasm aside, the pressure alone would be enough for most managers to never dream of giving a player his first career start in this kind of situation. Moore went out and pitched 5.0 innings of shutout baseball, gave up four hits, walked only one, and struck out 11 on 84 pitches. Beginner’s luck you ask? Only if it lasts for two games, because his very next start was a 7.0 inning, two hit, six strikeout, shutout against the highest MLB batting average team, the Texas Rangers in Game One of the ALDS. This guy has ice in his veins, and has already demonstrated he has what it takes to face the best lineups in baseball during the most clutch situations. He will not be overshadowed for long, and will someday be in the $200 million dollar contract range.

Print Friendly

About the Author

Colin Hammond


HOUSTON, TEXAS - APRIL 04:  Daniel Ochefu #23 of the Villanova Wildcats (C) hoists the trophy after the Villanova Wildcats defeat the North Carolina Tar Heels 77-74 to win the 2016 NCAA Men's Final Four National Championship game at NRG Stadium on April 4, 2016 in Houston, Texas.  (Photo by Streeter Lecka/Getty Images)

SportsCorner, Episode 43 (NCAA Tourney and NBA) – 4/8/16

This week’s episode begins with the thrilling National Championship game between Villanova and North Carolina. Was it the best title game we have ever seen, and how does it leave its mark on the overall tournament? From h...
by Tyler Ratts


SportsCorner, Episode 40 (#iubb and NFL Free Agency) – 3/10/16

We are back in the SportsCorner Studio and have a jam-packed show this week. First, we review the year that was for Indiana basketball. How do we describe the season, and what makes us nervous moving forward? Then, we examine t...
by Tyler Ratts


SportsCorner, Episode 29 (College Football and NBA) – 10/31/15

We’re back in the SportsCorner studio, and this week, we have a wide variety of topics. First, we give our midseason predictions for the college football playoffs. Should Notre Dame make it in over a one-loss Power 5 team...
by Tyler Ratts